As we sit back and wait for it to all be over, I can't help but put down a few thoughts about what has for almost everyone been an ugly, mean-spirited and divisive election that has cast a pall far beyond the borders of the US. One of the things that has bothered me the most about this election is the position of the so called moral majority or Christian evangelical community. Their position as always is to support the republican party simply because they claim to defend conservative moral values. What I find baffling is that when the republicans picked Trump as their candidate - a man who himself demonstrates no moral values whatsoever - most evangelicals seemed to turn a blind eye and continue to support him.
The conclusion I have come to is that many US evangelicals are so concerned about defending their specific agenda, they are willing to compromise everything else that being a Christian should be about. When Jesus walked this earth, he cared about the sick, widowed, poor, marginalized groups and those seen as the worst sinners of the day. That Jesus would be appalled at the image that the term Christian or evangelical evokes for many in America today. The golden rule - love God and love your neighbor - seems completely lost on them. What seems to have happened is that defending a couple of token values has become an idol to the point where all other core values like tolerance, caring, peacefulness, respect have been thrown out.
I realize that there is something core that seems to resonate between Trump and his supporters. Trump is seen as a powerful figure able to face down the status quo and steam roll over all his opponents. The idea is, who cares if he is a thug, so long as he's on your side. The problem is that this is a devils bargain. By supporting a thug to get their way, there's no guarantee that any supporter might not become a target of that same thug when the thug's mood changes. Its like school yard politics - some side with the bully because it seems safer, but in the end the bully is a bully, cares only for himself, and you're in trouble if you're near so long as he remains unchallenged. When you sell out your soul and values to get one thing you want - you may get the thing you're obsessed with but lose everything else that really matters.
Ultimately this approach seems to me about as unchristian as can be. I call it selfishness. If I am able to sell out everything to get one thing I want without thinking about the consequences for others, then I'm being selfish. Trump worships himself. His supporters are willing to overlook this because at their core they don't care about their neighbor. They care about defending their property, their families, their selected core values, and if everyone else is excluded - thrown out over the wall - so be it. So at its core its not just the politicians that are mean spirited in this campaign, its the very core philosophy and values that are driving the Trump campaign that are built on meanness. Its by design.
Admittedly, we all have a selfish streak from time to time and want to defend what's ours. What I have trouble stomaching is this whole idea that somehow to support a thug like Trump is the Christian thing to do. A valueless, selfish, hateful, abusive and disrespectful person like Trump is so far from anything Christian, that supporting him from a Christian perspective is simply incoherent. If you want to support Trump because you want a wall, or you feel he defends your interests somehow, so be it. But don't call it a Christian position, or even worse, demand others support him because it's the Christian thing to do.
I think this whole situation evidences that the Church in North America is in crisis. Christians have lost a sense of relevance because many of us have lost our connection to the core values our faith was built on, that of service and caring, not judging and imposing. There will need to be some serious soul searching to clean up the rubble of this election and avoid it walling up the Church further from wider social society.
As to the whole 'crooked Hillary' campaign, I don't buy that. In general, I'm no constant proponent of any one party or candidate. My biggest problem is with people who vote as a knee jerk reaction, and that applies to either side. Of course Clinton is not without her faults. She's made plenty of mistakes and should be held to account the same as anyone else. Still, these pale in significance when compared with the core of what Trump is all about. Clinton's mistakes are the kind we might make every day out of neglect or lack of attention when overloaded with too many responsibilities. Trump's worst acts are not mistakes at all, but simply flow out of who he is, his complete obsession with self worship, and disdain for anyone or anything that opposes him - including institutions of law and democracy. Who else would use $20,000 from his own charitable foundation to buy a 6 foot painting of himself and place it at one of his Trump hotels? This has happened more than once. You can't make this stuff up.
Yes, most elections are a choice between the lesser of 2 evils, and these choices are rarely easy. Its just that this time around the math seems a lot simpler than it usually is. On a more humorous note, I like the idea of last week's presidential election in Bulgaria where you can just vote for 'nobody' if you want. This might have saved a lot of people a lot of consternation in this election. I'm just not sure what happens if 'nobody' wins.
part 2
ReplyDeleteAs for Trump. Welcome to the real world.
He is a populist and has a soft heart. Goes with what works, uses whatever/whoever to get the most profit out of it. No one really knows what you will get with Trump, but I tried to describe best with March/April weather (should state weather for North/Central Us & Canada, certainly not Florida Arizona!)
He care about himself first. And we will make himself great again. Already has. Like any grumpy old grandfather has a soft heart and can be manipulated to give the keys of the kingdom away….
He might have plan, God only knows.
Speaking of God and lazy people… How them Christians lining up to get into bed with Grandpa? Really? Trump’s views on people, on the planet on values aren’t really Christian class acts. So what gives?
Hey it is the society of immediate satisfaction. And Trump is all about that. So jumping on his train is going to help highlight, underline, enforce all those great Christian values, us against them, eye for eye, follow those commandants, get your butt in Church, and generally praise the Lord we are saved with Trump again mentality. Can’t wait…. Argh.
And you wonder why I am not crazy about going to church…
Definitely Christ’s message of loving God and all that he made is not really being heard. I am afraid of what the US might do now with climate issues, with inequality and with justice. Trump Sharia law might just come around…who knows what Grandpa will do.
Think the policy issues you outlined are way too dramatic. Trump will lurch and weave to whatever pleases him. He will make messes (and at times I think fix things too) as he bobs and weaves through the political wilderness. But yes, America has become a laughingstock, like the UK. And sadly now who will be the balance on this planet.
Perhaps it will be good, we all will take responsibility and stop relying on one power. Though that is a bit utopian.
I am not smart enough to sort through it all, but pragmatic enough to know March / April can be messy so I trying my best to get myself et al covered /protected as best as possible. Think of it as surfing in the metro to destination unknown….
I resisted commenting until a few days passed from Trump’s victory and the Democratic collapse. Some perspective was needed to kind of come to grip with this outcome.
ReplyDeleteChange is coming, just not in the gift boxed happy present you were expecting. It is going be many months of March/April weather, unpredictable & messy.
What does this election say us, good good question.
Look at why Hilary lost. All the modern trending faults are there. Lazy, presumptive, expectant, illusionary, and the sense entitlement all brought her dreams back down to reality.
She didn’t work hard enough, she didn’t reach out to people who were disenchanted/ People considered deplorable were not listened to. Women were expected to tag along and vote for a female, like it was assumed they all would. Heck, Hilary threw in an awful video feed of Trump speaking awfully about women. No need to talk to women about any doubts they might have her now, right? The proof was in a 10 year old video!
53% of white women voted Trump. 46% didn’t vote at all. Who was Hillary speaking from July til November? The video didn’t work, nor did any of her plans.
How is it an email scandal from years back kept biting her? Why couldn’t she manage this issue, bad staff? Poor attention to detail? Lack of understanding how it could be used against her? Probably all three.
And the issue is not what is in the emails, but why she couldn’t put it to bed years ago and get it behind her. She needed to. And she didn’t. You can apply this theme to how she ran her election, not enough attention to detail, didn’t work enough on the issue, underestimated the potency of the issue, and not respect to the opposition how to use it.
That is one problem current society has. 93% of people think they are smarter than average. So it can’t be me who is stupid, and if so they are too stupid to understand. I deserve my moment and I am going to get it.
So enough about Hillary. Let’s say she lost, hilariously.